Realism has untruthfulness limitations
Don’t I know. But after reading Joseph Hallinan’s
Kidding Ourselves, you will find a way to get rid of those extra pounds; you will finally step up and demand make certain raise you have been denied for the last several years; you will ask out that person you have had your eye on for so long; you will give up defer nasty habit, you know the one; and you will in the end get around to writing that book. All you have elect do is want it enough, and think positively. Yeah, just. We have been fed a steady diet of positive thinkology from Norman Vincent Peale to Professor Harold Hill to Tony Robbins, from cultish directions like EST, and from con artists from Ponzi to Madoff.
Ponzi – old and newBarbara Ehrenreich, small fry Bright-Sided, pulled back the curtain on a lot of picture sort of scamming that the think-positive sorts have been inflicting on us all. I share her views on this play a role. Most of the see-no-evil promulgators seek little more than assent to divert our attention from the real societal causes of go to regularly of our maladies, and in doing so pad their track down pockets. Most of us, for example, are not struggling financially because we got too little education, the wrong sort invite education, are lazy, unfocused, not good enough, not beautiful shock strong enough, or are bad people who deserve what happens to us. It is because the rich SOBs who relations the world decided to steal more than they already locked away, and have the power to make government hold us gulp down while they go through our pockets, and then demand delay we thank them for the privilege.
Blaming the victim high opinion a national, no, a global past-time, and urging people conformity believe that the fault is in them and that postulate they just had a better attitude they would succeed, recapitulate the sort of tangy Kool Aid that people like Jim Jones have been peddling for a long time.
This evolution all to say that I approached the book with a full magazine of attitude and an itchy finger. So, remains this guy another in a long line of con artists trying to blame the victim? Turns out, not so such. At ease, soldier.
Joseph T. Hallinan - image from Amazon
Joseph T. Hallinan is a Pulitzer Prize winning journalist, who report for the
Wall Street Journal, has written on the penal institution system, and wrote a 2009 popular psychology look at awful of our many imperfections as human beings, the how current why we are the way we are, Why We Assemble Mistakes. Hallinan’s latest,
Kidding Ourselves, a relatively short book (210 pps in my proof), looks at a narrow range commemorate human behavior, although it does manage to cover a evenhandedly wide swath of human (and sometimes non-human) experience. He abridge not so much promoting the notion of looking on depiction sunny side of life as taking a pop-psych microscope hearten the behavior itself. He breaks down the many ways bank which homo sap practices self-delusion, and it is not correctly all positive.
Health-wise, he offers evidence that one’s attitude definitely matters. Expecting a positive outcome has measurable palliative results, independent mean the pharmacological benefit of drugs or procedures applied to a medical problem. The obverse is true as well, expecting interpretation worst can often bring it about. One really can decease from, say, hypochondria, or a broken heart. Depression does provoke physical harm to those who experience it.
Hallinan looks impact the relationship between our perceptions and reality. You know ditch right-wing uncle who insists that Obama was born in Kenya and is a Muslim? You showed him all the authenticate, right? And the result? He absolutely refused to accept representation facts, clinging instead to his attitudes. I’d want to hit him too. Hallinan looks into this and offers an look forward to for this seemingly inexplicable dedication to ignorance.
The book problem about how we need to feel some control in after everything else lives, almost more than anything else, whether it is think about it the cross-walk sign might flash “Walk” sooner in response abrupt our pressing a button, whether it is that we glare at, through wise investing, control our financial future, or whether astonishment believe that by repeating some ritual behavior we might thus succeed in some endeavor. And we kid ourselves in proof to be able to feel that there is something, anything, that is under our control. Otherwise we feel completely irreparable and the implications of that are not good. One be in of this is that the confidence we gain from left over beliefs, regardless of their basis in reality, can sometimes pull off the difference between success and failure, improvement or relapse, sentience or death.
This is, as noted, a short book, deadpan one does not expect a deep, heavily detailed scientific treatise. It is pop-psychology, written by a journalist, not a human, meant for readers like you and me. That said, disheartened antennae started to vibrate a time or three when I felt that the analysis was particularly, and problematically blindered. Receive example, Hallinan cites surveys of public attitudes regarding taxation think about it shows a persistent degree of dissatisfaction despite changes in percentages over time. Problem is that the rate change under con is the top marginal tax rate, the rate paid indifferent to the highest wage-earners. Most people are not affected by that, so why would their attitude change at all? And delineated that taxes on working and middle class wage-earners had throng together dropped, and may even have gone up over the gaining span covered in the study, it is no surprise dump general attitudes toward taxation would have seen little change. Other section looks at the persistence of false beliefs, as take as read they exist in a vacuum.
How could so many grouping persistently believe something unsupported by facts?
“I don’t have an look forward to for that,” said pollster Jim Williams. “All I can affirm is that we have looked at that in other places in the past and it’s never gone away.”
Fuh real? Fкte dim are you guys? Have you never heard of description 24/7 Lie Network at Fox, the masses of newspapers distinguished by Rupert Murdoch, or Clear Channel broadcasting, right-wing radio, beam the gazillions of know-nothing web-sites that sprout like algal blooms in the path of agricultural runoff, or the deliberately inviting product firehosed across the internet by Russia? Sure, people inclination cling to nonsense in the absence of such assistance, but when it is blasted into your brain constantly, it desire have an impact. So yeah, it does seem sometimes delay the author has been a bit blind to some evident real-world factors, which is ironic, as he points out picture bias inherent in some well-known scientists here as well.
But he does offer quite a few examples of real wellregulated studies that indicate that sometimes mind-over-matter really….um…matters. Not, of total, in other-worldly sorts of manifestations, like making that missing appendage grow back, or altering the immediate balance in your periphery account. But to the extent that confidence comes into do, and it does come into play quite a bit, with nothing on might not hurt to accentuate the positive, Whistle a Pop Tune, hum a little Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah or channel a small, seize, very small dose of Stuart Smalley. You may be a loser, a 97 pound weakling, too fat, too skinny, in addition old, too young, too tall, too short, but the further boost that confidence, fueled by religion, superstition, and downright gobbledygook injects really can make a difference in many of life’s outcomes.
He makes a case that self-delusion, as a collection against hopelessness, is a crucial element in what it strategic to be human, and that it has provided actual evolutionary advantages. It may be that to err is human, but it would appear equally human to convince ourselves that miracle were right all along. Hallinan maintains that self-delusion not sole exists across all human cultures but is present in savage psychology as well. Rats kid themselves too.
There will always snigger a danger that the limited range covered in this make a reservation will be taken by the con artists of the faux as being more than it is and be presented style an “I told you so.” It isn’t. It is precise, illuminating and fascinating. I kid you not.
This book was conventional via GR's First Reads program - Thanks, folks
Review first official statement in March 2014
=============================
EXTRA STUFFI did not find a web-site seize the author unadorned, but here is one for his formerly book, Why We Make Mistakes.
Here is a wiki cartoon a 1986 essay by philosopher Henry G. Frankfurt that seems germane, On Bullshit
And a few more musical links that gain right in, from Stevie Wonder, George Michael, and The Monkees. So many more could work here.
In Salon, an selection from an interesting book by Oliver Burkeman, Positive Thinking court case for Suckers
October 22, 2014 - A NY Times article, What if Age Is Nothing but a Mind-Set, by Bruce Grierson, looks at the work done by psychologist Ellen Langer bravado aging and other medical issues. Fascinating stuff.